Jump to content

Carbon Fibre Versus Fibre Glass


captain_moog

Recommended Posts

Hey Guys,

I have been really getting into fishing recently and found some rods in my pops back shed.

They are both about 2.4 metres long however, one is fiberglass and one is carbon fibre.

I was wondering if you guys could tell me the strength and weaknesses of both types of rods and what type of fishing i should be using them for.

Thanks for your help,

Ash

Link to comment
Share on other sites

when you say carbon fibre It may be the treverse x range they are now hard to find

and where a great rod in there own right.

Depending on the exact length and line rating it it is hard to say.

i would say land based rods as they as you say 2.4m long which is around the 8 ft mark

most boat rods are 7ft or under but now a days 8 ft is still exceptable as 8ft rods cast a little longer ie for plastics etc.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

id be really interested to see a few pics if possible of the rods and to know what the ratings are as well as if there arer any makers names on the rod

on a semi rleated note in a similar activity a while back i found my great grandfathers split cane rod and suspect from the information i can gert trhat it was a rod used for fishing for blackfish dating to about just before 1900

Link to comment
Share on other sites

G'day Ash,

As the other members have said, post some details and you should get some more guidance.

About glass vs carbon fibre (aka Graphite) rods in general... carbon fibre is much more responsive (stores and releases energy more efficiently... so it can cast further), is more sensitive, casts more accurately, is lighter and stronger (with some limitations I won't bother with)... but, it's also more fragile and more expensive.

Most people prefer to fish with carbon fibre rods where practical and their advantages make them particularly good for spinning & lure fishing... but almost any fishing is better with a CF rod.

One areas where glass has some advantages is rock fishing... it's much more resilient to being knocked around. Any ding, crack or gouge in a CF rod can see it explode in a shower of pieces when subsequently put under load. Not a good look!!

Cheers, Slinky

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hey Guys,

Thanks for all your replies so far, they have been really helpful

I have been out to my pops and took down the information of all the rods (there are 4 of them so i thought id post information on them all for some feedback. Ive got pictures if needed but i dont really know how to post them

Rod 1

Brand Shiman

Model Technium

Material Fibre glass

Length 6”0’

Line weight 2-4 kg

No. of pieces 2

REEL

Brand Shimano

Model FX 2500 FB

Line Diameter

Line cap (lb-yards) 6-200 to 10-120

Rod 2

Brand Vega

Model Boat series 2289-240

Material Carbon Fibre/ Glass tip

Length 2.4 m

Weight 0.220kg

Line weight ????

No. of pieces 3

REEL

Brand Daiwa

Model Sweepfire 4000

Line Diameter 0.3-0.35 mm

Line cap (lb-yards) 10-300 to 14-210

Rod 3

Brand Flexy Stick/ Aerostar

Model Flexy Stick/ Aerostar

Material Fibre Glass

Length 2.4 m

Weight

Line weight 5-10 kg

No. of pieces 2

REEL

Brand Golden

Model JK3000

Line Diameter 0.3-0.35

Line cap (lb-yards) 10-235 to 12-185

Rod 4

Brand Crane Sports

Model

Material Fibre Glass

Length 5”8’

Weight

Line weight 15-24 kg

No. of pieces 1

REEL

Brand Crane Sports

Model SL600

Line Diameter

Line cap (lb-yards) 45-460 to 55-310

4:4:1 Gear Ratio

6 Ball bearings

I think its pretty safe to say that Rod 1 is for very light fishing and Rod 4 is for more heavy stuff. I was hoping that you guys could tell me the limitations/ range of conditions that each could be used for.

Thanks heaps,

Ash

Link to comment
Share on other sites

G'day Ash,

I think two of the problems might be that your question is so broad (there are often a lot of different styles of fishing you can do with any one outfit) and also many of those rods & reels are obscure brands.

The Technium rod and Shimano FX reel is a light outfit probably most suited to estuary bait fishing for bream, flatties, whiting, etc. While the line rating suits soft plastic fishing, the rod is a bit on the short side.

Maybe someone will know a bit about some of the others.

Cheers, Slinky

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...