I have just upgraded to a Renegade 460 with all the fruit from a cuddy cabin and couldn't be happier. Spent over 12 months looking around getting a feel for the different offerings and price points.
Things I learnt over the last 12 months;
Don't rush it
Decide on what you want to do with boat, fish, family days, etc.
Decide on where you want to do the above.
How much do you want to spend, don't forget the extra's.
Involve everyone who is likely to use the boat as well (wife, kids)
Bigger is not neccesarily better when you consider storage options, using it one up, towing, the list goes on.
Price is a generally a big consideration for everyone. What I found is i could get the Renegade anywhere from sub $30K up to just over $40K. Why the difference in price? The main seemed to be the motor that was fitted anywhere from a 50hp up to a 75hp. You are better off with a slightly smaller boat with the max recommended hp rather than a bigger boat with a lower than recommended max hp.
The other difference in prices was the options fitted, keep in mind it will be more expensive to fit options after you have purchased.
One thing I wanted was a full transom and found only a couple of boats had this at that size.
Good luck with your purchase.