Great work there Hutcho, sounds like great day to me.
As for the line it could have been the different aspects of where the line was floating i.e.. because of the different thickness and properties of the line the bait could have ended up in a different spot or presented the bait in a different spot because you were using floaters.........
,,,,,,,,
.......
........
........
or he's just a better fisherman than you
B.F.